Christ Church MS. 154

Provenance and Acquisition

This manuscript is, in truth, less significant than it has sometimes been claimed to be. Kitchin rather hopefully noted that ‘this is probably the original MS. of the work’ (52), even though Cavendish composed his work in the reign of Mary and the script of our manuscript can be no earlier than the very late sixteenth century. It has also been said that it was ‘probably used as copy for the first published edition’ of The Life (Paul Morgan, Oxford Libraries outside the Bodleian, 2^nd ed. (Oxford, 1980), 28), but the differences between the text here and in the printing for William Sheares in 1641 [Wing C1619 and cf. C.1619aA] are significant enough to require us definitively to discount that possibility.

Perhaps Kitchin was encouraged to make his mistake by giving too much credence to a note at the inside of the front board: ‘This book was wrote in the Reign of Queen Mary’. That note had been crossed out by the time that Kitchin came to see it and replaced with a note immediately below it, in a different hand: ‘See Anthony Woods account of the Cardinal wherein Is drawn up a Better account than in this Author as I think[.] Note A. Wood in his Athenae P 280 vol 11^us says that Tho: Storer ^Student^ of Xt Church wrote the Cardinals life in 10 shettes in quarto in English verse & printed it in 1599’ (on Thomas Storer (d. 1604) see Matthew Steggle in Oxford DNB). The author of this note is probably responsible for the few marginalia in the manuscript (fol. 4, 12, 16, 20^v and 92), and perhaps for the note at the inside of the lower board (‘Cawood 7 miles from York’). It is possible that their author is Thomas Tanner.

There is no explicit evidence for the context of the production of this manuscript or of its early history. This uncertainty includes the date of transcription: Kitchin, as we have seen, is over-influenced by pietas when he dates it ‘saec. xvi’; Sylvester, in his edition, suggests ‘ca. 1600’, while Peter Beal in his on-line Catalogue of English Literary Manuscripts proposes ‘c. 1630’ [last accessed 9^th May 2014]. The positioning of the marks of a chain staple is unique in the ChCh collection and suggests that the volume was chained in another institutional library before it arrived in its present home. This hypothesis gains weight by considering the chronological limits for its arrival in ChCh: it is not recorded in the 1676 catalogue (at which point those manuscripts which had been chained were liberated; see Appendix I); it is, on the other hand, present in that of 1717, with the shelfmark ‘L2’ (see Appendix II, and cf. Appendix III, B.18). Characteristically of the collection, the 1717 shelfmark is not recorded in the volume itself; the only one to appear there – at both inner upper board and top right of fol. 1 – is ‘E10’, the number it had in the New Library (see Appendix IV), entered into the volume by Edward Smallwell.

This is not the only manuscript copy of Cavendish’s Life in the Library. The next shelfmark, MS 155, is occupied by an eighteenth-century transcript, the origins of which are explained by a note at its first flyleaf:

Dec. 10^th 1741

This life of Cardinal Wolsey was transcribed from an ancient Manuscript by yᵉ care & at yᵉ Expense of yᵉ Rev^d M^r John Blackbourn M. A. formerly of Trinity College in Cambridge lately deceased, whose Widow by yᵉ hands of yᵉ Rev^d D^r Tookie presents it to yᵉ Library of Christ Church Oxon. where her Husband intended it should be deposited.

At the inside of the upper board, opposite this note, there is a cross-reference to our manuscript, written by Richard Hind, Librarian 1748–53 (on whom see headnote to Appendix II): ‘This Life was written by Tho. Cavendish: of which there is another Copy L.2 [with E.10 added in pencil]’. MS 155 has not been highly regarded: Kitchin notes laconically that ‘it is of no value’ (53); Thomas Vere Bayne, Librarian 1872–99, considered both it and this manuscript ‘very bad’ copies of Cavendish’s work (signed note added to the 1813 catalogue, MS Library Records 28, volume 2 sub Cavendish).